Petersen's Ice Cream Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Petersen's Ice Cream, a cherished gem nestled in Oak Park, Illinois. This super premium ice cream shop offers a delightful array of flavors that will surely satisfy any sweet tooth. Each scoop is a celebration of traditional recipes and the finest ingredients, featuring fan favorites like Caramel Ripple, Pistachio, and Rocky Road. The Strawberry Cheesecake is an indulgent treat, boasting real strawberry pieces blended into velvety vanilla ice cream.

Guests rave about the friendly service and nostalgic atmosphere. Many reviewers appreciate the outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying a sundae on a warm summer evening. David Loofbourrow reminisces about the community’s history with this parlor, while Carly V highlights the creamy texture and delightful flavors. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Petersen's Ice Cream invites you to experience a taste of tradition.

Location: 1100 Chicago Ave, Oak Park, IL 60302
Phone: (708) 386-6131

Black Walnut

Cappuccino

a combination of coffee and chocolate

Caramel Ripple

creamy caramel fudge s swirled in vanilla.

Chocolate

blue ribbon winner at the lllinois state fair!

Chocolate chocolate Chip

chocolate chips in chocolate icr cream

Cinnamon

made with ground cinnamon.

Coffee

Cookie Dough

chocolate chips & cookie dough chunks in vanilla ice cream.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

peanut butter swirls & chunks of peanut butter cups in vanilla ice cream.

Green Mint Chocolate Chip

chocolate chips in mint ice cream.

Mackinac Island Fudge

swirls of fudge & loaded with chunks of rich chewy fudge in vanilla ice cream

New York Vanilla

a hint of egg with a rich golden color (french vanilla).

New York Cherry

burgundy cherries blended in a french vanilla ice cream

Cookies 'N Cream

chunks of oreo cookies in vanilla ice cream.

Peach

juicy peaches blended in vanilla ice cream.

Peppermint Stick

peppermint candies mixed in our vanilla ice cream.

Pistachio

the traditional

Praline

praline pecan candies in vanilla ice cream

Rocky Road

mini marshmallows and almonds mixed into our rich chocolate ice cream

Strawberry

large juicy strawberries swimming in vanilla ice cream

Strawberry Cheese Cake

pieces of strawberries and cheese cake in vanilla ice cream

Turtle

loaded with swirls of rich caramel and butter roasted pecans in chocolate ice cream